Welcome to Polito's Pizza
Polito's Pizza, located at 960 Main St, Stevens Point, WI, offers a delightful dining experience that combines a fun atmosphere with diverse pizza options. Known for its signature offerings, like the 14" Tomato Basil and 20" Meat Amore, Polito's serves made-to-order pizzas baked to perfection. Regular patrons rave about the irresistible garlic knots and unique specialties like the Mac & Cheese Pizza. Guests appreciate the friendly staff and quick service, making it a perfect spot for family outings or casual gatherings. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a slice to go, Polito’s promises a satisfying and memorable meal.
-
960 Main St, Stevens Point, WI 54481, United States960 Main St, Stevens Point, WI 54481, United States Hotline: +1 715-341-9980
Welcome to Polito's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Stevens Point, Wisconsin. Located at 960 Main St, this cozy pizzeria has built a reputation for delightful, mouthwatering pies that cater to a variety of tastes. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Polito's promises an inviting atmosphere and a wide selection of delicious choices that will keep you coming back for more.
At Polito's, each pizza is crafted with care, featuring fresh ingredients and creative combinations. The standout items include the 14" Buffalo Chicken pizza, topped with Frank's Red Hot sauce, mozzarella, cheddar, tender chicken, and a sprinkle of red onion—an ideal choice for anyone craving a spicy kick. For those who prefer something milder, the 14" Tomato Basil pizza offers a refreshing blend of sliced tomatoes, basil, garlic, and a gooey layer of mozzarella atop their signature pizza sauce. There’s also a unique 14" Mac & Cheese pizza, a creamy delight that surprises and divides customers, as seen in mixed reviews, proving that taste can truly vary!
For those who enjoy sampling, Polito's also offers pizza by the slice—just $4.25 for a classic cheese slice, perfect for a quick bite on the go. And if you have dietary preferences, check out their 10" gluten-free pizza, ensuring everyone can join in on the tasty fun.
Patrons rave about the cheery, welcoming vibe of the establishment. Customer experiences reflect the dedication of the staff, with service consistently described as friendly and efficient. One fan, Andrea Nevermind, highlighted how Polito's is where her cravings lead her when she’s back in town, emphasizing the restaurant’s consistency in delivering flavorful food with minimal wait time. Cheri Barnett echoes this sentiment, praising the fun atmosphere and the remarkable garlic knots, a crowd favorite! The nostalgia and warmth felt at Polito’s make it the perfect spot for family gatherings or friendly meet-ups.
While some customers express mixed feelings about the Mac & Cheese pizza, others can’t get enough of it. Sterling Wall playfully critiques it while admitting his kids adore it—perhaps a testament to Polito's diverse menu accommodating all ages and palates! There's something magical about sharing a space filled with laughter, great music, and the delightful aroma of pizzas baking in the oven, making Polito's a haven for pizza enthusiasts.
With reasonable prices that allow families to feast without breaking the bank, it’s clear that Polito's Pizza has become a cornerstone of the Stevens Point community. Come for the pizza, stay for the atmosphere, and leave with a smile—or maybe a slice to go! Whatever the reason, Polito's Pizza is an experience worth indulging in.
A fun atmosphere with lots of options and amazing garlic knots!!
An absolute must take family and friends too. When they visit town. Steak and fries pizza is the best! Garlic, knots and cinnamon nuts are a toss-up, bowls are just awesome. But the mac and cheese pizza... No. Just say no. That's not pizza. Come on you guys even though my kids love it
I had a great time, the food was heavenly, the music was somewhat appropriate, and the servers were kind. Recommend! (Mac and Cheese Pizza is my natural favorite)
This is the ORIGINAL Polito's!! The location in my town closed, and I've been CRAVING their Mac & Cheese Pizza. While in Point recently I was excited to be able to get it! Located downtown. Cute area. Parallel parking in front of the store, left side on Main St. Angled parking stalls on the right. No issues finding parking on a Thurs at 8pm. Pizza by the (big) slice. Full pies also available. After you select the variety you want (prob 10 - 12 kinds to choose from) they'll bake it a few more minutes to get it melty and crispy! We each got 2 slices, ate one, and took a slice home. Garlic Knots were good (4 are a half order). We each ate one and took one home. Had 2 large sodas. 24 pre tip: 2 people (4 servings total with leftovers). Service was easy going and friendly. We asked for a soda refill, and the young lady was pleasant. Staff was cleaning tables, emptying trash and tidying up as we were there. The beverage cooler had been restocked while we were eating. Our table had been cleaned before we sat down. Polito's is consistently tasty, affordable pizza, that's pretty much "fast food" because there's very little wait time. It's a great option!
Love coming here with friends. Prices are pretty good. Able to feed 4 people for only like 30 bucks. The place feels very friendly and nostalgic. Kind workers. It does get really really busy at times though.
I was working in the area and decided to grab some pizza. What I like about this place is they sell pizza by the slice. I ordered the pepperoni and the chicken quesadilla pizza. I also got an order of fries. Everything on the pepperoni pizza was balanced just right. The sauce didn’t overpower the cheese and vice versa. The crust-to-sauce ratio was even. The chicken quesadilla pizza was fabulous, and the toppings all worked great together. The fries were good, nothing special, but they are fries. The service here was excellent! I will be back the next time I’m in town
My wife and I ate there yesterday for the first time I had the Italian beef. It was incredible one of the best I’ve ever eaten in my life.
I really enjoy the reheated slices, you can pop in, grab a few and be back out in 5 min. Their mac and cheese pizza and chicken bacon ranch are awesome!